Once you’ve finished writing your book, the next big decision is how to publish it. Should you go the traditional route, submitting your manuscript to agents and publishers? Or should you self-publish, taking full control of the process?

There’s no one-size-fits-all answer. Each path has its pros and cons, and the best choice depends on your goals, timeline, and personal preferences.

In this blog, we’ll break down the key differences between the two best-known publishing models—self-publishing and traditional publishing—so you can make an informed decision.

1. What is Traditional Publishing?

Traditional publishing is the classic route—getting your book signed by a publishing house (e.g., Penguin Random House, HarperCollins, or a smaller independent press).

The Process:

• You submit your book to literary agents (most big publishers only accept agented submissions)
• If an agent accepts, they pitch your book to publishers
• If a publisher buys the rights to your book, they handle editing, cover design, distribution, and marketing
• You receive royalties from book sales

Pros of Traditional Publishing:

• Credibility & Prestige – Being published by a major house adds authority to you
• name
• No Upfront Costs – The publisher pays for editing, printing, and marketing
• Wider Distribution – Your book can be stocked in major bookstores and libraries
• Editorial & Marketing Support – You work with a professional team to polish and promote your book

Cons of Traditional Publishing:

• Highly Competitive – Most publishers reject at least 95%+ of submissions
• Long Timeline – The process from submission to an agent to release of your book can take 4-10 years
• Loss of Control – The publisher owns the rights to your book and makes final decisions on cover, title, and edits
• Lower Royalties – You typically earn 5-15% per book sold, compared to 35-70% in self-publishing

Best For: Writers who want credibility, mass distribution, and don’t mind waiting for their book to be accepted.

2. What is Self-Publishing?

Self-publishing allows authors to publish their books independently, using platforms like:

• Amazon Kindle Direct Publishing (KDP)
• IngramSpark (for wide distribution
• Apple Books, Kobo, and Barnes & Noble Press

The Process:

• You write, edit, and format your book
• You hire professionals (or DIY) for editing, cover design, and marketing
• You upload your book to publishing platforms
• You keep a higher percentage of royalties but also handle all marketing

Pros of Self-Publishing:

• You have full creative control of the project – You make all decisions on editing, design, and pricing
• Faster Publishing – You can release your book in weeks, not years
• Higher Royalties – You earn 35-70% per book sold (compared to 5-15% in traditional publishing)
• No Gatekeepers – No need for approval from agents or publishers

Cons of Self-Publishing:

• Upfront Costs – You pay for editing, cover design, and marketing
• Marketing is 100% on You – If you don’t promote your book, it won’t sell
• No Major Bookstore Distribution (Without Effort) – Bookstores rarely stock self-published books unless you actively pitch them

Best For: Writers who want control, higher royalties, and a faster path to publication.

3. The Money Breakdown: Traditional vs. Self-Publishing

One of the biggest differences between these two paths is how much money you can earn.

Royalties Per Book Sold:

Traditional Publishing:                            5-15% ($1-$3 per book)

Self-Publishing:                                            35-70% ($5-$10 per book)

Example Scenario: If you sell 10,000 copies of a $14.99 book
Traditional Publishing: Earns ~$7,500-$22,500
Self-Publishing: Earns ~$52,500-$105,000

Self-publishing makes more sense financially if you can market your book successfully.

4. The Reality of Marketing: Who Handles Book Promotion?

If you self-publish: Marketing is 100% your responsibility. You’ll need to:

• Build an email list and social media presence
• Run ads on Amazon and Facebook
• Pitch your book to podcasts, bloggers, and influencers

Example: Many self-published authors make six-figure incomes by running targeted Amazon ads and email promotions.

If you traditionally publish: The publisher handles a minimal amount marketing, but you’re still expected to:

• Promote your book on social media
• Schedule podcast interviews and speaking gigs
• Engage in book signings and launch events

Bottom Line: No matter which route you choose, YOU are your book’s biggest marketer.

6. Which Publishing Path is Right for You?

Choose Traditional Publishing If You:

• Want credibility and bookstore distribution
• Don’t mind waiting years to publish
• Prefer having a team handle editing, cover design, and distribution
• Are willing to earn lower royalties in exchange for prestige

Choose Self-Publishing If You:

• Want full control over pricing, design, and content
• Are ready to market your book (or learn how)
• Want to publish quickly without waiting for approval
• Prefer to keep higher royalties and earn more per sale

At the end of the day, both paths can lead to success—it just depends on your goals and priorities.

Awakening Author Blogs